从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]p

¨

pgAq~wlqAqoAiqIAYAqSxghPlqAPyWqACOlqbA]A[FFPC]AlqFAulqC

WAeYFgqFvqpFAxlqgvAqAClOAAFqAlAiuvv

1

upqvAbAYCOq

lqAqpnFTPAPb~[WAqAFpPbWq]qOqMwA

vACqAqAOq]YqgqAqPgCYvAPytvq]self-dealing¡[qAMOlqA]vlPAeYqFAhlqFAbtYqvd

1

CtAYqWd[ASOOAWdAYiotA2

C

uvvwqAiT184C2

eqAblqMq[WdAM~owWtdApBBgqAAYioPOqvAo]qatAPWdPCYqaF]controlling shareholders¡AqOdCAYF

513

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

AbeAqFqAAv~qFinqAlqAohWs]IhFWw]qBiBqIFqv

6

3

YoTBnACFFiF4

5

AniqvWd]qT]qTBq]AFFMC]OAB

A

AqtqlC

qAFvdATC3

MAYqlq90¢WwoAqTWwAqFYqvCWdAi~]EBTWwCoOAq]FPWdCTTWwAbPpAqFivC 4

plqYqAYAqTnCE~_PlqAYO]_PPAlqEqAPq_qCAOAO_nqAOnlqATYAlaq]ivAdYAWdvCPitAWdrAmqP~nA64¡]2000~5vWdAiTC 5

lqlqFO_tqA~WwuqMAFqAAByCvwCBAqPerOA32A16¡]2003~7CAC6

YqAuoqP]WTSOvAIFaYgqCuvpBh]Y]phhqWMethod)¡AYPtAqF]FWiosq[IAMqvqCWAqYlqPqAivCitOCAqYuvAqYlq]AAAqYq~gttAqyqAMlqobCOAqFiiqlAAqtlvdFtAqYuvAqCWoAnBAM]qlqobCoqA]bW[TApqWoAotB]iOql][AFiOvT

514

qPqCAg Auv(Purchase

AqC]Aq

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]p

MAAlqFoqgbMwWATOACFFPivWwOAFYOqAlqqOAnOAlq]JqAWF]q]AvWqqAVlqlvCB

AqAlqFA7

lqFAAlq~AWwAvWqlvqlAo]E

OAqPgOlqlqOauFC]AWAaFoA]OBvBq

FOpql

MqPg~O

C

AsdOq8B8-1

CAq

FoWwAnvWtBlCWqAi_Amq]WnA74¡]2002~11[¥_]W]¡CAiAmqsnAFdhA29-35¡]1981~6CepBhAiOAq~pBxW_irApsA187A141-47¡]2001~6C 7

BYiYqFiVF_]direct actions¡CeAieWdC 8

MqlqMWwAqqlqFtqCdi]ET~CwFefAAE~wuWWdqvuhvWwWWdquOFAuCBFtqAoq~WqgCvMYwAuhFOAFAiq]tqCAhqlqFtqAiCAFdqqlqMPrAmPnA342¡]1999~C 8-1

oOAFqCWwAqA

]MvOAodWdAg~qPwSwAYnFAPMPqCAv~TWdA~quqsEv~TWwWdYOq~AFPCWwAAYxq~ASPFeYA

515

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

OlqM]pAMeAqTEYO]WdO_OlqFvqAy~WqygpAOwuvqaAiu]pAWOlqsWd]C]OAlqAqJvApvYioOAMSlqFtvdAoSeqFC

qtAYlqgqAOqeWFv]pAnF~AqglP10

qPlqioqpCboAThOA]rqAvA~Fv]AWdCpiqgvwqA~Fv

9

uCnAqoB

M]pOqodAi~OAM~]pASFoAVvAoYniBCAWw]TB

WwAeipieFAFxq~Av~TAlqsEWw]gE~EETWwAPWwTAAMWwAAbWd]E~Cx]]TrCqFtqOA~qPAqCWwhAFWdAWqoqpPAlqtqAiqlqFtqCWdAqv~TwIWwAtdOlqAlqFC 9

MA]iquv~FvqAsqa]tquv~FvCoAAYiATEWwCA]pAFAOC10

WMTEWw

BCYAMIAOJImblqqeWAOM]pAF~qOAOlqFPvCYF]pqlqFPvtqOtPdvuvdvAqAiOFB]e2OP[

CvFSAqCWAi_ql

AYbYlqMP]pAMuBCMAMuWvAMWweA

516

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]p

TAwgsqoApvFY] lqqeAYWdAlq]pAqWdpAWwqpCaAoWAWAYW

APWd]pCPA[FvqqCtbWAY~

vBE~xWPPFs

ovBiuAbvC

]cash-out mergers¡qClqBAFBA]lAi[YASO]C

WaWobbABeYhASOoJAsJIAblqCA]pioAqWd]pAB~OWd]sbqF]dAbWdWePpC

AAehsAAlqBAYql~At~]gWA]APupqPAE~AqoAWdAivPvWAoioeFAsshSWwP]pAFaoqqeA]_CAM]pJYFCYOAMMSJ~Fv]pAoSqdCFhCrAqnb~FvlqlAb~WiM~AoPq]BWdABPFqeCWAqMO]M]p[cPrA63A271-321¡]2000~6FPeArAaesJAOAApBM~v]pAMqqfAYOVOVClqWd]pAiPFlqgoAOlqFPvAi_FCAPAiqqATC

517

qlAFqlqTTS104A470-492¡]2000~10C

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

ulvPgATBAAACAAFx~AiqxWT[11

uyW[v[IAwioq]piiVAE~WqFB~

A]ioABC

§lqWdP

WwAeAeWMatoAOFCbqoFCWwAYM~OCuWMav

12

CuWMaAO_~wAWpwAWwC

11

xWPT[O12

gET~grETTCCtoqoBBhWwC

AqBO

oqlMF]AlFAWMaM~P_AYpvBvP

qrBqrC 518

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]p

13

qTCWwAqPqAAAFCtWwAqMAFqAAByCO_FtqAqh_w14

C

qlqEWwo]EWwAqoAgqTWuubMtlFAA

vCAAYsqosAWsqwo

MvABIqF]B

Wsqb]AsqoAgsqTWuubMAlFC

T

t~Ablq]]AeBpAYqlqAqCWwAqAqAi[M

15

CAWwAh

13

AC

14 e5C

15

519

A

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

qYWwCYqgAqvOAPoqqABqPqwqWA~W]YMC

u……¥~iqYqPqMA

vAeq

qTWwAAqMAYqpAYlqAPqqAqAfdCSqvCAlqA

vPqBC]AMqWAlq]]AqlqlqA16

CWwYbwPWwAoWAoPq17

C

T

eipie]FAFvAFPqlAyYPqqCWwAo[JMCvgE~grECEC

16

AhFxq~CO

Aqs ……¦17

gE~CgrETC

520

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]p

oqiAM_ATSwFqF]5¡FClvTFF]10¡sqvqF]T[Tw]2¡oF

]6¡wpqF]8¡]pF

]11¡nwF

]3¡PqW]

18

CT]A4¡]1¡qPqYAwqlq]AO_vTFv]7¡sqCb]9¡ww]12¡A19

C

]AqTCWwA

AOC]1¡qWAsqWs]qWF]2¡sqs]q]oBqF]3¡sqs]q]qFtosBF

qPtoF]4¡qAFtoIAWwF]5¡sqs]qEqC

qeAoeMFlqAoeFC~AlFeAoqnweAFesPF]MaFqIFA

O_P20

CBpAqlqneAY]AB

]BWMaC

18

oqoBBhTWwC

19 oqoBBhC

20 oqoBBhTWwC

521

AP

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

T

TWwAW]d]qY21

AVosAqWwO~A

t[AOePBvfAWwOi22

CTWwA

qbeAVICAWAqObFMAAPeAVICAPqFAbfwA~eC

eAS]1¡pee]AB]B~BTpePwpqBpBwwBvTBCbBCl

vTBqvqqFF]3¡WMavF

s]F]5¡qPqvtF]6¡q~gpvd]

]qoqA]ogpvdF]7¡qMFCtWwAbF

]8¡q]~p23

C

~ASOOAOPv24

CPeA~P~oPoPiOnIIAWosAC]1¡PFq~]po~]vTAd

PF]3¡WosAA 21

YAsqsC

22

oPoBhWwC

23

qoOhWwC24

qoOhEWwC

522

]2¡]4¡o]2¡

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]p

dPFvTAdPA]AFFF]iii¡vqw]B~BToBBPOFvqvTPwpqA[C

vYoPoAAC

]4¡Wos]ii¡peinAwpiAFpeA[iFT~o]B~

d26

o]i¡B]iv¡o]v¡25

dCS

peAAWwAqMAwouFMvbPCqFewBAowuFMvTWPClFAqnl

eqlqYMCWwAqYlqvAMvipuFMvAbC

25

lFiMtMveWw~AFTWFuAYoqAuobFuAAsqlFC27

C

]pAAFPMvAip

<> (last visited July 12, <> (last visited July 12,

523

2004) 26 27

2004) gE~grETC

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

AqpwMqFPCv]pAOFOAhqvCSoCPAvqAYo

bAAFoqAqTFvAqFhCtAWwvqAFvC

T

bAWwAFFeVqAF 28

_AqvsrAOAe6¡A266-67 & n.57¡C

FPA]FAF

vYFqvTvAvAgFA28

C

WwAs]lCEWwAlqAsq]vTF

fYgOA29A183¡]1981~2F_]W524

AP

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]p MvAlvvTWwAlqFqiqwAVlqvnCAneCtA BF

bAWwAFAFFM_AOBCqhCFM_A_EIFYFMFgTAnAW_AIwCbAqFovACbAFVlqAMFMpC Bnw

eWwAYFPqFTAnwCn]bOxe]Tn]BA]AB]

A]M~A29

qTCWwPWwPASOuAAWwC 30

gE~grEEEC

29

CbAPMiqAbAlqFovAOAFqAo30

BqCAPFqiYFPqFAqM

_FAwAqwWwA

AFWwFnAVqbaCnAnCnOFqBCC

C]Abw

525

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

eATqtdnFFnAodq]pAwCdPqO~AnwAAi]E

t~AFqAbqeAqCqCPIPA

IlC

TWwAIA

SAgwAidFqbtCC

wAiw~ApWAoru]EwiBpWAEwAyCvwAbYPq]qYW]dqAYqFMAMwFblqM

t~AAg~q~pCWwA~bAbCSPaCSph]W[C

uqTCyA

dnawCAC~xrWwAoruaAYFMA]AAwAMwC

upABTWwAAYy]P~C

31

CT]TCv

31

gE~CEgrEEC526

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]p

qWwAFYF]M_Abw_OuPqVnwvvCt~Av]w

eiAqnFqASqIqIeAFaAoqMAFMTFMCMMAMTweAFwgwoqAAiFYFMPFMTMFvAO

upqvAYpql]pqlpnq 32

TAmg[Ivn

BFM_AwAhYqPMAFAF]hOC

vYIAF~qC]AbCYFbvWAiFa_MPwFYbMPMTMPIAF]wFFAbqIeAA]MwsbA32

C

AFhA167¡]2003~5C

527

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

]ppb]aqCC~AbeWqWq]qAuMpq_AbgpCP~_FElACA~lOApqpuqTBpTBCBpnq]pBpnq]33

34

AApqAYPpqBFAhx

Abqbx

ApqpBppqAoAYq]aqpTAYT

35

qBpBCbByqFvqqwCpqhqlTW[TdATYAq

C

Ygl

63.5AeawaTPCC~AC

3-1-3¡AB1999~628C

]~h

pqAvCApqqeF27¢CbEtApqaoSqlFP]~lpJACt 33

bhoA80.536

AT A

TYm~PnA628]34 ~xWq~heWwAWqYpePWqAWqxWqWfdh]WfdhwO

A_hq]WosoWCWwYFWqAaWeqAWqFCAhOeaWAbWCAnup~AsqCbWqCbvAPWosoWCtAWqi]pCWqqaWAPbWCWwAn]WqBP10¢vFAWfdWwAoWsOAWqFBosAaW]Cpq]2303¡Y]AoWepPpqC]2339¡A~YPWFp]BuAYWeAfC 35

±E~AxnqwBnqAOdAYpqqC 36

xWuTTvAiC

AaaWqAsqCbAWqrC

528

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]pCbpqAquaWqA]]CFACuevOCPApBpPpTaqA~]nC~pAt]IA]ApBYBCAipl

FM]3-1-3¡ABBB0.02¢A]aWC~ApqAguiAW[CWuW[FTAiBABtWAgW[TAYeCCdTdlAbW[dCppqC]CpAgsW[FCosWYgOb

pBpBpTaqvoAoTaqOT~gvCpApqgitFsx37

AupqvOuMv

ChPA

u~wlv38

C

37 OtpCqOiOgObTaWqWAPbpqsW3¢vC75.5AoCYtpq]hAq63.575.5Wq]66AuviYOyWFAoICtApqgATiWAaWqYpCpqF_]pAhOoACoIA]YAqFo_VqgvAWeAJC

38 m~PnA628APe33¡Ct~A]Jbm~Pn

MpqAAA[WhBvBW[AYiq]ABgapMFBWqAi]WFTBoAVWCAbpWAMFApA]OiTCY[M~]gApqgC

529

5.512¡

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

5-1-1 ¡

]88.6.14-89.12.31¡

T

Áp¹q¶°ÎºXU¤-®a´¹¶êN¤u¤½qA]ApqB

pBpBpAOlAPMaaqApqsqAlaqhC

qvpq 1

p 1Ap 3Ap 1.35A 2Cpq88.06.14

YqqBpBCbByqFvqqwCaqep1,224ATY883AqC

pqq~CT¥l¶}¤KQ¤K~²Ä¤@¸Á{ɪѪFAC

ACq~Cl]EPS¡3

4ApFCApqMYAI~

88.06.15

¤-¤ë¤îA¦Xõ¤½¥q²Ö-pÁ«·l¹F12.45AwC

t~AwFCnA]lOvYq

39

AOAOC

530

39

]O

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]pq

BpBCbByqFv

qqwCYyqpAPwp]pqBO63.5P40.5A1.571¡C

vA~FMwC

pq]h]A63.580.5AuuWTF

27%¡ChOq

88.06.21

40.5A36.9ATF

8.9¢CaqqAeqTCO~At]A]1¡vaqo]]]APAF

]2¡88.07.06

vqwF]3¡aqFoFvF]4¡YoaqFPAaqÀò±o¬Ûö¥DÞ¾÷Ãöº®Öã¦X¨ÖAvTqOCewupqvgqvqA88.07.29

WwA](88)¤r8807497-002[(88)¤r616iM

wC

531

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

pqaqPlFAyAMqCFMwnsx88.07.30

1,064,977,320]FCd

toAF

CnC

¦X¨Ö¨Mij«áA³qª¾ÅÅv¤H¤Î¤½iAwTAnvoC

88.08.03

pqVWosWAWfeTAnpqbSebAlPWAoTpuMP]x]88¡WrTTC

88.08.11

532

从美国法之观点检讨我国母子公司合并案例与相关之规范...

q[IlqPWd]ppvpvupqvu¨Ö´«ªÑñ¨ÒX²z©Ê§½ÆÖ·N¨£vCpvAYWhACB88.09.15

¤ñ¨Ò-pºâ·JÁ`¸ê®Æ]¥i°Ñ·Óªí3-1-6¡Ap]a_uAt~AqqC

MovvCnwnfA]AaABPqgh88.10.12

ABBdqBAoOPvTPoC

~PiCnwnA]AaAaqBpBPq¸gÀ綥h-±Í»PÁ|æ·|³¡A»`BBd88.10.12

CWospeTinAwpiBvwpiqC

533

本文来源：https://www.bwwdw.com/article/vf01.html