Responses to comments (英文期刊 审稿意见回复)
更新时间:2024-05-07 11:27:01 阅读量: 综合文库 文档下载
- responses推荐度:
- 相关推荐
Dear Editor-in-Chief in XXXXXXX:
Thank you very much for your help in processing the review of our manuscript (Manuscript ID XXXXX). We have carefully read the thoughtful comments from you and reviewers and found that these suggestions are helpful for us to improve our manuscript. On the basis of the enlightening questions and helpful advices, we have now completed the revision of our manuscript. The itemized responses to the reviewers’ comments are listed in the succeeding sheets. We hope that all these corrections and revisions would be satisfactory. Thanks a lot, again.
1. Title: XXX
2. Manuscript type: Article 3. Corresponding author: XXX 4. Full author names: XXX
Sincerely,
Prof. XXX
School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, XX Key Laboratory of Controllable Chemistry Reaction & Material Chemical Engineering, XX University,
Wuhan, Hubei, 430072 , P R China.
2015-03-05
1
Responses to comments of Editor
Thank you for your serious and constructive comments on our manuscript. According to your suggestion, the manuscript has been revised as a letter to editor. The revisions we have made are as follows:
? 1 Subtitles \Conclusions\\Acknowledgments\and \References\Reply:
Thank you for your constructive and helpful suggestion. The relevant subtitles have been revised in the revision.
? 2 In the section of the References, title of cited paper should be removed, and in ref.35 the superfluous comma should be deleted. Reply:
Thank you for your constructive and helpful suggestion.
All the titles have been removed as you required and the superfluous comma in ref.35 has also been deleted.
? 3 Numerous relevant papers have been published in recent years especially in 2014 and 2015. Some key, important or/and latest research results in this field, should be mentioned and cited in the section of introduction instead of outdated or earlier papers so that we can provide a solid background and progress to the readers regarding the current state-of-knowledge on this topic. Therefore, I strongly require you to rewrite this part and then update your citations. Reply:
Thank you for your constructive and helpful suggestion.
We have rewritten the section of introduction and updated corresponding citations as you required. In detail, some recent and excellent researches have been cited in the revision to replace those of earlier papers which are no longer
should
be
revised
into
\
Conclusions\
\
2
novel.
? 4 Any changes or revisions in the text should be highlighted by different color in the revised manuscript compared with that of the previous version. Reply:
Thank you for your constructive and helpful suggestion. All the changes and revisions have been highlighted by cyan.
We have revised our manuscript again
We have made further modifications on the manuscript, especially the introduction section. The latest revisions are highlighted by green, while previous changes are highlighted by cyan.
To be specific: a) Some adjustments about sentence structures have been made to increase the diversity of expression.
b) The second example about N-doped carbon materials is relatively early research result published in 2009. Thus we have replaced it with a lasted and outstanding paper.
c) The unique effects of S-doping have been expounded in the revision to correspond to the effects of N-doping introduced above.
d) In addition to rewriting the part of introduction as you required, we have also polished and revised the chapters of experimental, results and discussion, conclusions and updated the section of references.
The initial examples about N-S-codoped carbon materials (references16 and 17) are earlier results published in 2012 and 2013. Thus we have replaced them with some lasted and outstanding papers.
3
正在阅读:
Responses to comments (英文期刊 审稿意见回复)05-07
PageMaker排版设计简明教程(六)05-30
ABAQUS算例105-23
面试时如何进行自我介绍03-14
材料力学1-14概念答案04-28
内部与外部看门狗定时器的比较12-19
Tableau BI-Introduction 20120909-01
链路负载均衡 方面的描述05-30
- 多层物业服务方案
- (审判实务)习惯法与少数民族地区民间纠纷解决问题(孙 潋)
- 人教版新课标六年级下册语文全册教案
- 词语打卡
- photoshop实习报告
- 钢结构设计原理综合测试2
- 2014年期末练习题
- 高中数学中的逆向思维解题方法探讨
- 名师原创 全国通用2014-2015学年高二寒假作业 政治(一)Word版
- 北航《建筑结构检测鉴定与加固》在线作业三
- XX县卫生监督所工程建设项目可行性研究报告
- 小学四年级观察作文经典评语
- 浅谈110KV变电站电气一次设计-程泉焱(1)
- 安全员考试题库
- 国家电网公司变电运维管理规定(试行)
- 义务教育课程标准稿征求意见提纲
- 教学秘书面试技巧
- 钢结构工程施工组织设计
- 水利工程概论论文
- 09届九年级数学第四次模拟试卷
- 审稿
- 英文
- Responses
- comments
- 期刊
- 意见
- 回复
- 2016届江苏省南京市高三年级第三次模拟考试历史试题
- 鸭子沟大桥分部工程施工方案 - 图文
- 成都信息工程工程导论2实验报告 - 图文
- 迷踪六爻十二宫
- 2bizbox实施手册
- 编译原理复习题 (1)
- 市政给排水设计规划要点
- 江西数学联赛获奖名单
- 生物化学下册作业
- 新标准英语第一至六年级英语句型
- 2 CRH3型动车组牵引与控制特性分析
- 词法分析器实验报告
- 中国大地财产保险股份有限公司光伏组件产品质量及功率衰减保证保
- 2013年 卫生职称考试 公共卫生 中级 专业实践能力
- “信号与系统”复习题A(2010)参考答案
- 从所给的词语中选择正确的词语
- 长沙理工大学路基路面综合设计水泥路面设计计算书
- 广东省中小河流治理工程格宾石笼应用技术要求(试行)创新
- 《增支部》与《增壹阿含经》对照表 - 图文
- 营养与疾病